>>3286
I just came here to post my reviews and found you already posted yours today. What a coincidence!
>first spoiler
I still felt bad for Cesar. I think he truly loved Sophia, even if he couldn't change his ways. But then again he wasn't going to change in a day for a girl he met once after a long time being a playboy. If you were young and pretty with girls groveling at your feet, would you not take advantage of it and become a playboy? Because I think I would.
Anyway, here are my reviews...
<Abre Los Ojos / Open Your Eyes [ALO] (1997)
Cesar is a handsome man who lives alone and earns his living off of a major restaurant chain which he inherited from his parents. His wealth and looks afford him a comfortable lifestyle and a way with women, earning him the reputation of a playboy. He spends his free time hanging out with his best friend Pelayo, who is average looking and not as popular with the ladies, especially next to Cesar. When he's not working or hanging out with Pelayo, Cesar gets it on with Nuria, his bedmate who he couldn't care less about. Nuria knows this but still yearns for Cesar, she keeps it cool and casual but you can immediately tell she's obsessed with him... We are later introduced to Sofia, Pelayo's shy but adorable new friend and crush. Cesar steals her right away, of course, but Pelayo doesn't make a fuss. Meanwhile, Nuria is furious and wants Cesar all to herself, so she lures him into her car and they go for a ride. They get into an accident, Nuria dies, and Cesar lives but with an extremely disfigured face. Soon his reality and dreams bleed into each other.
Hope I didn't spoil too much with this synopsis, now on to the review...
ALO is a pretty tense film. You get drama, thriller and even a hint of sci-fi. But at the core lies a very simple idea; what would you do if the only life you knew was taken away? Cesar's transformation from the handsome carefree playboy into the ugly paranoid creep was both realistic and heartbreaking. I loved the scene where he meets Sofia for the first time after the accident, there were no special effects whatsoever yet everything felt so surreal. And that wasn't part of a dream.
Nuria's character was also played masterfully, barely speaking yet her eyes say it all. The desire, the loneliness, the sadness, and the thoughts of suicide. The scene where she's in a red dress driving her red car was truly mesmerizing, and her last line before the accident was nothing short of haunting... When Cesar looks at Sofia and sees Nuria, you can tell it's still Sofia because that's exactly how Sofia talks and acts. Whoever played Nuria did an absolutely stellar job.
Sofia's character was more subtle, but she played the part beautifully. She still liked Cesar after the accident but was naturally repulsed by the disfigured face. I like to think that what really drove her away was Cesar's actions post-accident, and not the accident itself. Pelayo did a great job too as the supportive friend, it shows when you care about someone even if he's not always nice to you.
<Vanilla Sky [VS] (2001)
The plot is more or less exactly the same as ALO, so no point in repeating it.
When I watched VS my first thought was "this is flanderized as hell"; the characters from ALO have become so exaggerated that I felt absolutely nothing for them. David (Cesar) is a filthy rich megalomaniac, Brian (Pelayo) is a "funny" Yes Man, Sofia is too eccentric, and Julie (Nuria) is bloody hysterical.
We have "Tom Cruise playing Tom Cruise" for the first part of the movie. Cocky but always smiling and being nice to everyone, including Julie, who is also always cheerful for some strange reason. Maybe it's just me but I always thought Cameron Diaz had crazy eyes, which could have worked for Julie's character if she was written better. More on this later. Sofia is played by the same actress from the original movie (Penelope Cruz), and her character remains a Latina which is nice, but in a way she got reduced from Sofia to "the quirky Latina". She still did a great job though, in my opinion Sofia is the real star of VS. The worst of all was Brian, he was simply terribly written.
The word "overselling" also came to my mind. Every little thing in this movie is explained through excessive dialogue, but instead of fleshing out the story it has the opposite effect of reminding you that everything you see is fake. Many scenes in VS had completely new dialogue, but still had lines from ALO mindlessly shoehorned in. It's almost as if the producers wanted a new "Hollywood experience" but felt an obligation to keep as many homages to the original film as possible. VS clocks in at over 2 hours, longer than ALO, yet somehow feels rushed because of all the dialogue that was crammed in... And did I mention the music was bad? ALO keeps it simple and classy with orchestral music throughout the film, while VS goes for pop and rock songs. I guess they wanted a more 21st century soundtrack which is kinda understandable, but even then there was simply too much music even in scenes that didn't need it.
There were other annoyances like applying the classic 2000s "smooth filter" over the movie, and of course turning it up for the dream sequences, as if it wasn't painfully obvious already. The CGI also aged badly, like the unnecessary "hologram man" at David's apartment, and that's coming from someone who loves old CGI. The only thing VS did not oversell when it should have was, tragically, the makeup for David's disfigured face. I imagine someone somewhere gave the order to make Tom Cruise disfigured but not too disfigured, so people could tell that it's still Tom Cruise and that he's still hot, maybe after a few drinks.
VS did introduce a couple of nice unexpected details such as Sophia having that chest mole and David plucking out that one gray hair. The ending was as "Hollywood" as it gets though. No way Sophia missed David when he died, she only met him once and he became completely weird afterwards. But then again she is "the quirky Latina" so anything is possible!
Some random thoughts:
You can't draw a Tom Cruise caricature without the center tooth, Sofia. He explicitly asked you to draw his flaws!
When David told the guy at the bar "I'm straight, OK?" I just lost it. Now that's rich coming from you.
Julie's delivery of "I mean, do you believe in god?" was simply disastrous. I can definitely see myself shutting the movie off at that point. Also she can't imitate Sophia to save her life.
What the HELL was that photo of Julie with the mutilated face? Why would David go this far? Why even show this on screen to begin with?
Strange how out of all the characters only Sofia had actual nude scenes, in both movies. Contractual obligations?