>>336415
True democracy is actual rule by the people.
Everything the government does is voted upon by the people.
No elected representatives or complicated processes of turning bills into laws.
Just the government putting everything up to a vote, and doing whatever the majority wants.
Plato was not against democracy of that sort, he was against democracy where we elected the people who fit into a structure that made the decisions.
People in that sort of system would elect the most charismatic charlatans rather than those who actually had wisdom, representative democracy is a glorified popularity contest.
But true democracy? That's something we've rarely ever had, and it feels like a bad idea, right?
Sure, because of all the stories about mob rule in the world of fiction "muh Socrates" and all that rubbish.
But the positive part of a democracy like that is in the things people would normally condemn as a flaw, its actually a feature.
- "they voted to have Socrates killed" yeah, and? Also if you look into it, you'd see that they gave Socrates every out and only gave him the option to kills himself, Socrates seemingly wanted to die. Hungry for the hemlock (tasted like martyrdom). I have a little bit of faith that the people will learn over time what not to vote for, if they do make it a matter of election to kill hated individuals, they will after a few executions by the ballot realize that holding executions by the ballot is a disastrous idea (since it leads the mob executing the next victim for the crime of getting the previous victim executed, as seen in that kinos journey episode).
- "you expect everyone to vote on everything all the time?" Do we currently expect everybody to vote in every election? No. So why hold things to the same standard here? My true response is this: the best feature of true democracy is that the people who want to vote on some particular matter will be able to do so without having to vote on everything all at once, which is the state with representative democracy. Those who vote on specific issues tend to be the most passionate and informed on those things, and so they vote only where their strengths are, unlike when they elect a representative who covers both the policies they do know and care about, and those they so not.
- "people are dumb and make dumb decisions, especially collectively" yes but I'll take dumb over evil anyday, and out representatives right now are evil, dumb changes and shifts over time as mistakes become something of public record, and over successive generations the mobs will eventually shift from having the worst takes be the most ubiquitous to having the best takes which keep getting better become the most popular. Also the stupidity is mitigated by the fact that people are only voting on what they feel they want to vote on, they don't have to case a vote on every policy as it is today with representative democracy.